13 Comments
User's avatar
Chris J. Karr's avatar

I'm going to sound like a broken record, but until Israelis oust leadership figures like Netanyahu and Ben-Gvir, there's NOTHING that the Palestinians can do achieve peace, even if they wanted to. Those Israeli leaders have no incentives but to draw this conflict out as long as they can, as that's how they retain their power[1,2].

The October 7th murder and rape spree by Hamas was a terrible atrocity - there's NO question about that. However, there was some method to that madness, and that was to bait Israel into overreacting and to turn itself into an international pariah, and it succeeded beyond whatever expectations those planners could have expected.

[1] https://www.npr.org/2026/10/07/g-s1-146776/israel-gaza-oct-7-attack-netanyahu-warning

[2] https://www.reutersconnect.com/item/israeli-minister-ben-gvir-poses-on-bulldozer-during-demolition-of-palestinian-home-in-jerusalem/dGFnOnJldXRlcnMuY29tLDIwMjY6bmV3c21sX01UMUFOQURMMDAwWDhCTjBI

Steve Berman's avatar

I'll give you credit for understanding the Israeli political system. Israel's voters can oust Likud anytime they want. They can invoke a snap election. It is the Israeli people who are venting wrath. The leaders are the ones they chose to have blood on their hands...nobody else wants that job so to Netanyahu it goes, over and over again, for decades. If the Palestinians even one time said "yes, Hamas must disarm" and Hamas agreed to any international solution--Egypt, Jordan, etc.--where they are under another force, Israel would be compelled to cooperate, and the government coalition under Netanyahu would flip. Then there would be some path out of this. At this point, there is no path. Israelis get it, and yes, they are frustrated. Many would love to see Netanyahu jailed, but as long as there's a war, this is how they choose to run it.

Eric Strickland's avatar

This where I depart from other contributors to the comments section of The Racket News. Portraying the Democratic Party has the more moderate cannot be squared in my mind with the Islamists running for and winning office as well as the misguided groups of Democratic supporters who drink the Free Palestine and From River to Sea Kool Aid. Trying to blame their perceived short comings of Israeli leaders as being the culprits to the continuing crisis defies all the history of Israel from the time of its inception. Israel becoming a so-called pariah state in the world view, is just another example of the rampant and historical hatred to Jews around the globe.

Steve Berman's avatar

We must reject the premise. American political parties are both being led by the nose by fringe extremists, charlatans, and illiberal thugs. Both the Democrats and Republicans, with normal people (voters) in the center, are reasonable, just with different prescriptions for policy. The problem is not in either party, but the leadership of both and the amoral application of money and power to politics.

Curtis Stinespring's avatar

Netanyahu has shown far more restraint than I would have. I believe in national security and borders and enforcing laws. Failure to do whatever is necessary to protect the citizens of a constitutional republic just makes a nation a target for enemies foreign and domestic. Today's weaselly statement by Mamdani is typical of those who resent the USA and its laws.

The below link is an article by a talented writer who comes as close as anyone to being a person I almost always agree with.

https://jackcashill.substack.com/p/im-glad-im-not-a-jew?r=d2084&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web

Nick Gibbs's avatar

74000 dead Palestinians is not restraint. It's hatred and a desire to destroy and obliterate.

Steve Berman's avatar

Get some perspective. If the desire was to obliterate, the number would be 2 million.

Jay Berman's avatar

Shall I take it the Jew hatred is fine because it is righteous?

SGman's avatar

Keep in mind that that number includes natural deaths (~25000, per recent statement from Hamas) - and shows a massive amount of restraint and intent to avoid civilian casualties in a dense urban environment against a force that embeds itself in and under the population.

Bill Pearson's avatar

History matters Steve, always has, always will. Clearly the ugliness (an understatement) of Oct 7 has evolved into furthering the hatred on both sides. Here's the other thing history has taught us: Hatred works; works to the point solutions are almost impossible.

I know how strongly you feel about this and like people on both sides of the argument, they are able to quickly justify it. When i saw the header and started the article, i was curious about one thing. Of late i have seen no less than 6 stories in news feeds that Netanyahu was warned well in advance about the kind of attack that took place Oct 7.

Any sense of whether that's true, or not?

Curtis Stinespring's avatar

The following link lists a number of stories about Israel and Palestine that Truthout has published and fed to the public. Truthout is just one of the similar news pushers long on accusations and short on facts. You can reach your own conclusion about their bias. There are dozens of such sites pushing left-wing and right-wing biases.

https://truthout.org/topics/palestine/