Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Thornton's avatar

Great post, Merrie! And the cat lady memes are fire!

Expand full comment
Chris J. Karr's avatar

When it comes to the pro-natalists, folks like the Collins are going to give the Duggars a run for their money when it comes to dysfunction once their kids are old enough to afford therapists:

"Simone and Malcolm want to show me that you can raise a family according to entirely rational, data-driven principles designed to alter the course of human civilisation for the better; that you can make large families work; that you can promote pronatalism without being racist. I am the first British journalist to see what pronatalism in action looks like by visiting the Collinses in their home. When I leave them, I will be utterly lost for words."

"Every decision the Collinses make is backed by data. 'Nominative determinism is a heavily studied field,' Malcolm tells me, when I ask about his children’s names. 'Girls that have gender neutral names are more likely to have higher paying careers and get Stem degrees.' Names like Titan and Industry are much more than gender neutral, I say. 'We wanted to give our kids strong names. We want our kids to have a strong internal locus of control,' he continues, as Octavian waves a plastic rubbish truck in front of my face."

"Their home is set apart from the nearest town, down a track from a main road, near a creek. When deciding where to live, they weighed metrics on a spreadsheet, ranging from LGBTQ+ rights (which they support) to the density of Nobel laureates produced in a given area to levels of homelessness to major weather events. Then, they looked at cost. They bought this house and the one next door for $575,000; they allow their neighbours to live in the second house rent free, in exchange for childcare."

Every time I see the Vance quote about folks without children shouldn't be running the country, I think of the Collins (who come from old Texan Republican insurance money) and shake my head that Vance thinks that yahoos who take their parenting cues from animal documentaries are somehow a better fit.

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/article/2024/may/25/american-pronatalists-malcolm-and-simone-collins

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts