Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Al Gonzalez's avatar

It will take the NTSB at least a year to release the report. I suspect due to the high speed impact that the Cockpit Voice Recorder and the Flight Data Recorder could have been destroyed. That may make the investigation even more challenging since they will just have the crash site, the ATC audiotape and other indirect evidence.

I hate to second guess the Captain who was 55 and apparently experienced. The picture I saw of their flight path through the cell looked pretty bad, why they turned lefts towards the cell is incredible to me. Had they turned right and avoided the cell provided ATC would have cleared them they would have been fine. They requested a climb after entering icing and that may have started the problem. They may have stalled in that climb and then lost control. That still picture shows no horizontal stabilizer and as your article states they found control surfaces away from the crash site. They could have also been in that classic “coffin corner” close to the Never Exceed airspeed and yet stalling because of the ice accretion. That cell was huge and looking at an image of it it really looks like they went through one of the worst possible areas of it, full of moisture, rain, probably wind shear and turbulence. God rest their souls.

Curtis Stinespring's avatar

A terrible tragedy like most aircraft crashes. Even if the sky had been more forgiving, finding an emergency landing spot in heavily populated areas would have been iffy. I sometimes stand in my driveway looking at the unending line of planes headed toward ATL (usually right over my subdivision) from the NE and wondering how pilots would pick a crash-landing site if the weather or their machinery betrayed them. Sometimes I can see the planes altering their approach many more miles to the west which I assume means wind direction is abnormal. Either way, the landscape is nothing but towns, subdivisions and crowded streets and expressways.

There will be a major shift in residential and business areas and travel once flying becomes impractical or much slower - think dirigibles and electric trains. Most business travel is already unnecessary. Vacation trips will become more time consuming and much shorter distances.

4 more comments...

Ready for more?