24 Comments
User's avatar
Merrie Soltis's avatar

No, I am NOT a NIMBY! My neighbors asked me to sign a petition to stop the county from approving a new townhome development. I refused. "People have to live SOMEWHERE." I told them. NIMBY's are the people who don't want others to use their private property as they see fit. They oppose backyard chickens. And painting your house a color that doesn't meet with their approval. Sometimes even flying the flag. Our area recently incorporated because they wanted to stop the building of - well, ANYTHING really. But specifically apartment buildings.

NIMBYISM is one of the most destructive forces in America right now. It's why we can't have high speed rail. It's why housing is so expensive. It's one of the major forces behind ICE forces occupying major cities. The NIMBY's want these people GONE. In the NIMBY mind, they aren't supposed to be here, they weren't invited, they weren't vetted, and they need to be arrested and sent back to where they came from, consequences be damned.

Of course, governments could do a better job of controlling growth. Maybe if they added lanes to the roads BEFORE they put up the apartments. And built new schools first. Growth is good, but it's not without its problems. Failure to address or even acknowledge those problems has led to the rise of the NIMBY army. But if you think you hate living in an area that's growing, you would REALLY hate living in one that's dying. There, the schools are closing. So are the hospitals. People leave. Jobs go away. Stores are shuttered. Sometimes, a city council puts together a program to lure businesses back, which attracts new residents. That's what they did in Springfield, Ohio. And we all know how that turned out.

Steve Berman's avatar

No Merrie. Those are just the NIMBYs you disagree with. The NIMBYs you agree with stand with you in opposition to them. We are all NIMBYs or we become serfs.

Chris J. Karr's avatar

If Merrie's YIMBYism is really NIMBYism in disguise, then does the term NIMBY really have any useful meaning?

From the way I've always read the term, NIMBYism walks hand-in-hand with keeping things the way they are and resisting the disruption of change.

Kim's avatar

As a Florida resident currently doing an Everglades study with my grandson I object to being called a Nimby. They Everglades is the source of drinking water for most of the state of Florida. Putting raw sewage and construction materials into the water is not good for the entire state. Having lights on 24 seven is not good for the wildlife. So you’re either in favor of treating people like animals and putting them in cages or you’re in favor of having a source of water for the entire state of Florida. The Everglades is actually the backyard for the entire state of Florida.

Steve Berman's avatar

But NIMBYs don’t oppose backyard chickens. Private property is private.

Chris J. Karr's avatar

The "backyard" in NIMBY is a bit more expansive than one's literal back yard. NIMBYs opposing things like high speed rail aren't doing so because the train tracks are literally on their property.

A NIMBY *would* oppose backyard chickens for the morning noise pollution from roosters, the smell of a chicken coop wafting onto their patio, etc.

SGman's avatar

Well, part of that is also how many developments are HOAs - and HOAs are effectively the local government...

Schools close when there aren't enough students or a large enough tax base to pay for the costs. Part of that is due to limiting growth (stagnancy is death), and partly it's people staying in-place after their children age out of the district.

The bigger issue with preventing dense housing is that it does lead to sprawl, which then requires even more resources - pavement for roads, sewer and water pipes, electrical/gas service, etc... - to serve the larger area.

Curtis Stinespring's avatar

Everyone does have to live somewhere but without planning, amenities and other facilities become unusable. There's also a reason criminals and other undesirables move to urban areas.

SGman's avatar

People live in urban areas because urban areas are desirable and productive. It's not a lack of planning: if anything, planning has been overly-stringent in many cities, leading to lack of development and investment. This leads to higher housing costs, displacement of long-term residents, and all that those issues bring.

Curtis Stinespring's avatar

All that changes quickly when capacities are exceeded and criminals. druggies, homeless derelicts, gangs and illegals move in. Then, the more normal people become targets and prey and victims.

SGman's avatar

And that's where the problem with capacity being artificially constrained comes into play.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 20, 2025Edited
Comment deleted
Merrie Soltis's avatar

Well, I hope that you are very comfortable down there in Dekalb County. Because my neighbors up here in Gwinnett are determined to keep anyone else from moving up here.

PJ Cummings's avatar

Astounding that you referenced “Cop City”. Well done. Surprised, but well done.

I shouldn’t be caught off guard, I guess.

Curtis Stinespring's avatar

My question is did you bring your wife down from up north or is she a Georgia girl? I've had the same wife for 63 years and I can't imagine her getting on a roof much less putting a tarp on one.