Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris J. Karr's avatar

I'm of two minds on this.

First of all, what you (and Jonah Goldberg) published this morning is probably where I'm at in my heart-of-hearts. I don't like the masks (and need to quit forgetting to throw mine in the laundry for a wash!) and I was very pleased that Chicago was going largely maskless this summer as we did the right thing with respect to the vaccine. I got my shot, so regardless of how the next couple of months play out, I'm not worried about the safety of anyone I know in my immediate Dunbar set.

On the other hand, as I've laid out in previous comments, I am annoyed (and periodically) enraged by the lack of compliance with the mandates in the few places we reasonably have the masking still in place (mainly the public transit system). I live in a city and neighborhood that gets a lot of out-of-town and out-of-state traffic, so it's not like I'm just riding the train with fellow Chicagoans who - for the most part (58%) - have gotten the first shot or more, but also from neighboring states who continue to punch themselves in the crotch with respect to COVID. (I'm looking at you, Missouri. Also, happy Lollapalooza weekend!) I continue to believe that it makes sense for the ongoing mask mandates on things like buses and train cars, not so much for me, but for the 42% of my fellow Chicagoans who still need the jab, so I don't think it's theatre as much as some folks (and riders) like to prefer otherwise.

As an individualist, I'll choose to keep adhering to the mandates, because it's a VERY short-sighted individualist who doesn't recognize that collective actions also create permission structures that can encourage or deter behavior based on what others around you are doing. Given that no-one has ever provided Step 2 for the scary Mask Gnomes (Step 1: Get people to wear masks. Step 2: ??? Step 3: Ultimate Power!), I'm going to continue to give my local health authorities the benefit of the doubt. For all the words that have been wasted on the. tyranny of masks, it's just a mask. Asians have been using them productively to protect themselves for years, and Americans going full crybaby over them really doesn't say anything positive about that vaunted American Toughness.

I think that if we start to see mask mandates expand out from where they are here, it's going to be a BIG political fight, even in this Democratic enclave. And I think it will be right to be a big fight. After putting the entire city on pause for a year, it's just getting back on its feet and I expect just about every business owner to shout that they've done their part, and they would be correct to do so. I expect the mask mandates to be political losers compared to the alternative approach of allowing businesses to requiring proof of vaccination for services. My hope is that we don't get to either point, but the fact that we're having this conversation is evidence of the lunacy of the world we live in.

As one of my friends once told me, we live in The Stupidest Timeline. I was hoping that a change in national skipper would have pulled us out of it, but we're collectively bound and determined keep authoring cautionary tales.

Expand full comment
HCI's avatar

Jonah Goldberg has a good piece out at the Dispatch, where he gives his well reasoned views on the recent mask mandates. Broadly speaking, it tends reflects my own views as well. It is worth a read.

https://thedispatch.com/p/backsliding-into-mask-mandates

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts