Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris J. Karr's avatar

I'm a HUGE fan of independent redistricting commissions, like the one implemented in Iowa. I'm a big fan of common-sense districts where objective mathematical rules are used to draw those districts, such as minimizing the borders of districts so that we don't get monstrosities like my own Illinois 9th District[1].

THAT SAID, if Red States choose to redraw their districts mid-Census cycle, Blue States are chumps if they take your advice and sit on their thumbs. The goal in doing so isn't an obsession with Donald Trump, it's all game theory tit-for-tat and extracting a price from the Red States that defected from the status quo first and eliminate any advantage there may be for a defector. They are not serving their citizens if they sit idly by and allow other states to press their advantages. (Red States already enjoy a SIGNIFICANT advantage with the over-representation of rural voters in both the Senate and the House.)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illinois%27s_9th_congressional_district

Expand full comment
SGman's avatar

Arnold should use his energy to push for a national proportional representation reform: get rid of gerrymandering nationally.

Just to note about Massachusetts: it's pretty much impossible to draw a GOP-lean or GOP-favored district because the GOP voters there are too dispersed. Illinois or Maryland are likely better examples to use.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts