8 Comments
User's avatar
Chris J. Karr's avatar

"Those numbers obscure the most alarming aspect of the decline. Public Religion Research Institute polling found that conservative identification decreases sharply with age. Trump and MAGA radicalism and corruption have severely damaged conservatism among Americans younger than 50. It is probably no coincidence that much of this cohort has no political memory of a Republican Party without Donald Trump."

One variable that would be interesting to look at is how Trump attitudes are different between voters who watched (or aware of) "The Apprentice" (2004 - 2017) and have an impression that someone is competent or business savvy just because they are on TV. My "Trump" is the guy I watched bankrupt companies repeatedly, and hawk sketchy goods ("Trump Steak") on infomercials. #MAGA's "Trump" seems to be the guy from "The Apprentice". Younger voters' "Trump" is probably just the President, the same way that I have no real mental version of Jimmy Carter or Reagan before they became POTUS.

Chris J. Karr's avatar

As for conservatism, I think that a strongly Federalist implementation is the only way out for our country, given that Washington is too centralized and sclerotic to be an effective mechanism for crafting and implementing most policies. I'd like to see a return to a federal gov't of strictly delegated (and clearly enumerated) powers, and a return of most policymaking to the various Statehouses, governors, and local legislatures. Brandeis' "laboratories of democracy" where States are given the latitude to experiment more with policy (and the freedom to get those policies wrong, and the responsibility for righting their ships), and other States can adopt what works well elsewhere and should work well in the local State context.

Unfortunately, politics today is a winner-take-all game, an NO ONE seems interested in the devolution of political power to locales where what the locals might choose something different than the person wielding the power at the moment.

Bill Pearson's avatar

As always David, fascinating read and one thought that jumped out at me was kind of askew from the whole conservative values departure by trump. Frighteningly, the last couple of days, it got a whole lot worse.

My mind roamed as i recalled how it started with Clinton and roared back to life with Obama. The view from the right was their efforts were to create a new world order. The allegations of a one-world government raged with Soros shaping the outcomes where mutually beneficial trade agreements worked for the greater good (of our allies). What folly.

It drove trump's quest to become president by chirping "America First," with the rubes eating it up. 10 years later, we watch in horror as the man stands on the stage with two men who have long been viewed as enemies to the United States. His joy of being there acting the fool is almost too much to take in. No, it is too much to take.

Does anyone believe the end game for trump isn't his own new world order? One where the three carve up and out their sections of the globe and profit personally?

For conservatives to come back, someone has to rise up and finally call trump out for exactly what he is. Until then, they will lie smoldering under the fetid stink of maga-ism.

Eric Strickland's avatar

David, despite the GOP being synonymous with conservatism, I don't think the Party as a whole has been majority conservative in my lifetime or will attain the majority anytime soon. Conservatives and all Americans need to become much more active in the primary seasons and vote for candidates with basic qualities that are valued by everyday Americans and not chameleons who always check which way the wind is blowing before deciding on an issue.

SGman's avatar

Semi-related: the DSA has been having a meltdown since the midterms as their quest for power required Democrats to win a narrow majority within which they'd be able to exert control over the agenda - similar to the House Freedom Caucus/early MAGA.

As they do only comprise 8 members and the majority far exceeds that - they'll be more or less powerless for this upcoming Congress.

Chris J. Karr's avatar

I'm looking forward to Curtis's take on the meltdown, since he was beating the DSA drum the hardest before the election.

SGman's avatar

You might recall that even afterward he was hung up on them, even when confronted with just how few races they even ran in.

Principles vs Tribes's avatar

We haven't had conservatism in a while, and everyone thinks politics have been terrible for a while.

Hmm....