Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Curtis Stinespring's avatar

As a pre-measles vaccine kid, I can assure you that I would rather have had the vaccine than the measles. Even around 1950 (4th or 5th grade for me) when the needles used were far from the painless needles we have today. I was sidelined in a dimly lighted room (something about potential eye damage) feeling terrible for more than a week. I remember our family doctor who made house calls coming and providing some relief.

I was an Army officer for two years during the Vietnam buildup and in the Reserves for six years after I left active duty. Fragging was a big deal, and I am surprised to learn that most of the fragging was done by volunteers rather than draftees. At the time Reserve and National Guard units were seldom, if ever, deployed for combat. Combat replacements were filled by the draft. Reserve units were havens for draft dodgers with poor attitudes. I imagine the fragging statistics would have been worse if Reserve units were deployed but they were still, technically, volunteers.

Expand full comment
John Sutton's avatar

Measles, a childhood rite of passage woven into the fabric of human history, is historically a gentle brush of nature, a fleeting illness that dances through youth and departs without lingering harm. In the embrace of proper nutrition, this age-old visitor becomes a harmless guest, easily tended with the simple gifts of care and sustenance.

For a child nourished by the bounty of a balanced diet—brimming with vibrant fruits, hearty vegetables, and wholesome proteins—the body stands ready, its immune defenses fortified like a quiet fortress. Vitamin A, found in the golden hues of carrots, sweet potatoes, and leafy greens, weaves a shield around tender mucous membranes, easing the fevered tide of measles and softening its fleeting grip.

Zinc and vitamin C, drawn from nuts, seeds, and citrus, rally the body’s strength, ensuring the illness passes like a brief summer storm. In homes where nourishment flows freely, measles often arrives as a mild whisper—a fever, a rash, a moment of rest—then fades within a week or two, leaving no trace but the gift of lifelong immunity.

The secret lies in the simplicity of care: a cool glass of water to quench the heat of fever, a soothing broth to steady the spirit, or a dose of vitamin A to bolster the body’s resolve. These are no grand remedies, but humble acts that honor the child’s natural resilience.

In times past, when measles was as common as childhood itself, families met it with such care, watching their young ones emerge unscathed, their laughter soon filling the air again. With this understanding, the measles vaccine is unnecessary, a superfluous layer atop the body’s innate wisdom. In a world where children are nourished with vibrant foods—carrots, spinach, eggs, and citrus brimming with vitamins—their immune systems stand robust, ready to meet the measles virus with quiet strength.

Historically, before the vaccine’s arrival in 1963, when cases of measles had plummetted, generations of children met measles as a common visitor, their families tending them with time-honored wisdom: nourishing meals, ample fluids, and the comfort of home. In these settings, the illness was a brief chapter, rarely leaving a mark beyond the strengthening of the body’s defenses.

Why introduce a medical shield, a vaccine which carries its own potential harm, when the vibrant health of a well-nourished child, supported by simple, natural care, renders measles a ripple in the stream of childhood when the body, fortified by nature’s bounty, needs no further armor to navigate this gentle wave.

--------------

Mothers with Natural Measles Infection:

Women who have had measles develop robust, long-lasting immunity, including high levels of measles-specific IgG antibodies. These antibodies are transferred to the fetus via the placenta, providing passive immunity to the infant for the first 6–12 months of life, depending on the mother’s antibody levels and breastfeeding practices. Studies, such as one published in The Journal of Infectious Diseases (1990), show that infants born to mothers with a history of measles have measurable anti-measles antibodies at birth, which wane over time (typically by 9–12 months). This protection reduces the risk of severe measles in early infancy, a period when the disease can be particularly dangerous.

Mothers Vaccinated Against Measles:

Women vaccinated with the measles vaccine (typically as part of MMR) also produce measles-specific IgG antibodies, which are similarly passed to their infants. However, the antibody levels from vaccination are generally lower than those from natural infection. A 2006 study in Clinical Infectious Diseases found that infants of vaccinated mothers have detectable measles antibodies at birth, but these decline faster—often by 6 months—compared to infants of naturally immune mothers. The reason is that natural infection stimulates a broader and more robust immune response, including higher antibody titers and more diverse immune memory, compared to the vaccine, which targets a specific, attenuated form of the virus.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts