18 Comments
User's avatar
Chris J. Karr's avatar

"The congressional committee has its work cut out for its investigators if they want to get to the bottom of who said what during those critical hours. They may never really find out. What’s certain is that for those house, its was more 'John Barron' in charge than the man who was elected president."

All the reason to throw the book at Trump and seek the maximum charges allowed under the law for breaking that law. If we don't, expect every other President we elect to "John Barron" everything that they wouldn't like reflected in the record.

Steve Berman's avatar

Nixon’s 18-minute tape gap comes to mind.

Curtis Stinespring's avatar

This is not really new. It may be difficult to prove all of your suspicions but I'm sure some violations have occurred in every administration including Trump's.

https://law.yale.edu/mfia/case-disclosed/trump-and-toothless-presidential-records-act

Chris J. Karr's avatar

This one of those instances where I was trying to see the silver lining of the Trump administration, where we'd see incidents like this (widely reported at the time), see that the laws and incentives were basically inert, and add to the list of "stuff to fix" for when some sane people came back into power.

Given that Congress still has yet to fix the Electoral Count Act - something that should have been done on Week 1 - I seem to be the only person who was paying attention AND thought that we should plug those holes.

I guess whether I like it or not, some Americans and a significant majority of Congress are perfectly fine choosing kings to rule over us and pretend that they are somehow accountable for their actions in office.

Curtis Stinespring's avatar

You probably aren't the only person paying attention. You have some good ideas. I do not think anything will change for the better until there are congressional term limits. Concerning the records act, I do not believe it is enforceable considering all the methods we have for communicating. It is mostly useless. Formal arguments and finished products should be archived. Not post-it notes and emails seeking opinions from someone's niece in Cleveland.

Chris J. Karr's avatar

A stronger and more consequential Records Act is definitely enforceable.

In my work with healthcare firms, there are very strict rules about the channels you can use to transmit patient health information (PHI). Those channels can be monitored and guarded for both archival and security purposes. If you're caught using alternative channels to transmit PHI, you just committed a data breach and are responsible for notifying the patients about what happened, fixing any issues your breach may have caused (such as paying for identity protection services, and monetary compensation), and even fines from the government, if the case is egregious.

If you want to be President or work in the White House, you agree that you will be communicating in your official capacity (which as the President is 24/7, 365 days a year, for four years) ONLY via those channels. No WhatsApp, Signal, etc. It doesn't matter what you're saying, if you're in the White House and using something different, automatic hefty fine and/or termination of your job (for everyone who is not President or First Lady).

If we DON'T do this, then we (the electorate) lose whatever accountability over the folks WE choose as President, because we lose the consequence that Presidential malfeasance WILL be discovered because their every communication is logged and archived.

This is entirely doable - the question is whether we have the political will to see it implemented AND enforced. Given voters' tribal loyalties, I might as well be shouting at clouds (and not the kind made out of servers).

Jill B.'s avatar

New or not, whether or not it's happened in other administrations, it displays a reckless disregard for history and a definite belief that he was above the law. Seriously, this is much the same thing Republicans were screaming at Hillary Clinton for.

Curtis Stinespring's avatar

The Secretary of State has no authority to compromise Top Secret documents. On the other hand, the President can declassify and make public any classified document.

I agree that lawbreaking is not a good thing. However, there is no penalty associated with the Presidential Records Act. It's just another example of Congressional posturing in an effort to show they are useful. They failed once again.

I suppose Congress could attempt another impeachment and continue the political theater instead of balancing the budget and protecting the borders.

Chris J. Karr's avatar

"On the other hand, the President can declassify and make public any classified document."

The President can do that. However, in the current Mar-a-Lago case, Trump was not President with those powers. Only a former President who once had those powers. Trump can't claim any classified documents discovered in his house are declassified if he didn't declassify them before leaving office.